Skip to main content

The MacBook Neo is built down to a price – but is phenomenal value

If there was one product that cemented the myth of the “Apple tax” – the supposedly excessive price premium paid for the logo – it was the MacBook Air. People would point to Apple’s cheapest laptop costing $1,000 and loudly proclaim that you could buy a Windows machine or Chromebook from around $300.

The comparison was of course spurious. The cheap laptops being used to make the argument were ugly plastic things with exceedingly poor specs compared to the MacBook Air. Still, it was undeniable that a four-figure starting price did prove a barrier to a lot of people – but all that has changed with the MacBook Neo

The pre-MacBook Neo era

Technically, of course, the MacBook Air long started at $999, but there really cannot be anyone left on the planet who falls for that, and I have no idea why companies still do it. The MacBook Air cost a thousand bucks and up.

I’d be preaching to the choir here if I enumerated the many and varied differences between this and budget Windows laptops and Chromebooks. Suffice it to say they weren’t remotely comparable.

You could, however, make the argument that the average undemanding laptop buyer had no need of the higher spec offered by Apple’s machines. If all you’re doing is email, web browsing and writing, then a cheap Windows laptop does get the job done. Some argued that if Apple truly wanted to live up to its values, it should offer something more affordable, even if that meant some compromises.

Until yesterday, the stock answer was that it simply wouldn’t be possible for Apple to make a Mac worthy of the logo at a significantly lower price. The MacBook Neo changed that overnight.

The Neo makes many compromises

Compared to a thousand dollars, $599 (or $499 for students) is a massively different proposition, and we can probably expect to knock $100 off that price at third-party resellers some way down the line. Within a few months, people are likely going to be able to pick this up for half the former price of the MacBook Air.

It goes without saying that it has only been possible to achieve this by making a fairly lengthy list of compromises. We yesterday provided a detailed comparison between the Neo and the Air, but let’s just quickly recap the limitations here:

  • 8GB RAM
  • Maximum 512GB SSD
  • Reduced performance
  • Slower charging
  • Lower battery life
  • Smaller color gamut (sRGB rather than P3)
  • No True Tone
  • Reduced external display support (1x4K versus 2x6K)
  • No Thunderbolt support
  • Only one USB 3 port (the other one is USB 2)
  • No Touch ID on the base model
  • No keyboard backlighting
  • Mechanical trackpad instead of Force Touch
  • Webcam doesn’t support Center Stage (and no physical indicator light)
  • Speaker and microphone compromises

That’s a lot. However …

It’s still phenomenal value

Once again, this machine costs $599, and will likely be widely available for $499 before too long.

Quite a few of the compromises made would be deal-breakers for 9to5Mac readers. Many of you didn’t even get past the first one on the list.

Top comment by Olive8Ball

Liked by 5 people

I feel like them using the a19 with 12gb of ram would have made this a better product but I understand the technical limitations are due to the SoC they are using. This product does prove one thing though that seems to be missed by most reporting:

The Apple A series of processors can run OSX. This literally means there’s no reason to not be able to run our choice of operating system on either the iPad Pro or the MacBook. Let that one really sink in.

View all comments

But we’re not the target market for this machine. This is the Mac Apple hopes to sell to many of those who would previously have bought that cheap plastic Windows laptop. The people who only use their machine for email, web browsing and writing.

The target market isn’t using the machine for video editing. They aren’t plugging it into a dock or external monitor. They aren’t connecting it to large external drives. Almost none of the compromises will have any impact on their usage.

So despite that lengthy list of limitations, this is the Mac I’m going to recommend to a lot of people. Sure, when I talk to friends about their needs, I’m sometimes going to end up recommending they buy a MacBook Air instead, or perhaps even a MacBook Pro. But for the vast majority of people, the MacBook Neo will be all that they need.

Did I mention the price? Unless you need to run software that will only run under Windows, you’d have to be pretty crazy to buy a Windows laptop instead of the MacBook Neo. Apple is going to sell a gazillion of these things, and rightfully so.

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.

You’re reading 9to5Mac — experts who break news about Apple and its surrounding ecosystem, day after day. Be sure to check out our homepage for all the latest news, and follow 9to5Mac on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to stay in the loop. Don’t know where to start? Check out our exclusive stories, reviews, how-tos, and subscribe to our YouTube channel

Comments

Author

Avatar for Ben Lovejoy Ben Lovejoy

Ben Lovejoy is a British technology writer and EU Editor for 9to5Mac. He’s known for his op-eds and diary pieces, exploring his experience of Apple products over time, for a more rounded review. He also writes fiction, with two technothriller novels, a couple of SF shorts and a rom-com!


Ben Lovejoy's favorite gear